In Letters from Birmingham City Jail, King described the four steps to a non-violent protest, and the first one is collecting the facts to determine whether an injustice exists. Until the world rids itself of this separation illness, all attempts to initiate a healing process will be impossible.
His civil acts of defiance were revolutionary since he supported a form of protest that did not incorporate violence. One could no longer ask another person to follow a law that supported segregation without revealing a lack of moral consciousness.
Putting Thoreau into consideration, he lived during a time when negotiation was non-existent. Civil rights activists believed that all men were created equal and therefore should be equal under the law.
When moral reasoning should be of the utmost importance, it is shameful that there is not of much backbone in history to support the claim that the U. Acts of civil disobedience will always occur because discrimination will forever exist.
Civil disobedience can be justified in certain circumstances because laws do not always apply equally to every individual. Such led to their somewhat different views toward breaking unjust laws.
Such shift in paradigm was necessary to achieve eventual equality in the society, for no significant change could have been gained without first changing the minds of those who opposed against desegregation.
Thoreau doubted the effectiveness of reform within the government, and by presenting his own experiences, argued that petitioning for change achieves little. They broke down the barriers of blind discrimination and made all things visible; they knew what was right and just and took matters into their own hands by taking action against society, which benefited everyone in and beyond their time.
Despite this fact, it is a concern for some people that the government rather seems to ignore the significant issues that affect us most, but invests its time and effort into other trivial issues.
The third step was self-purification. Although it is true that both believed that individuals should do what they believe is right in accordance to conscience and that an individual should refuse to obey any unjust government rule, they had a slight contrast between the ways they viewed the existence of a government.
While King stated that there should be some sort of governmental guidance, Thoreau stated that society, when ready, should prevail upon themselves without a government. He applied this in his compelling letter Letters from Birmingham City Jail, by redefining such basic concepts as a law.
Competing views of what were just and unjust laws were also the overall problem of the Civil Rights Movement, a movement of which King was a figurehead for. In the case of civil rights, such friction created by the government would be the one of racial inequalities.
Interestingly, more than one hundred years later, the same issue of civil rights and equality was tearing the United States apart. In his essay, King said that he must acknowledge that he had broken the law, and encouraged others to do so too.The essays, "Civil Disobedience," by Henry David Thoreau, and "Letter from a Birmingham Jail," by Martin Luther King, Jr., incorporate the authors’ opinions of justice.
Each author efficiently shows their main point; Thoreau deals with justice as it relates to government, he asks for,”not at one no government, but at once a better. Essay Editing Help. upload your essay.
argumentative. compare and contrast. log in × scroll to top.
Home; A Comparison of Civil Disobedience by Thoreau and Letter from Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King PAGES 6. WORDS 1, View Full Essay. More essays like this: civil disobedience, martin luther king, letter from birmingham jail.
In "Civil Disobedience" and "Letter from Birmingham Jail," Henry David Thoreau and Martin Luther King use different techniques to fully convey their own opinions on injustice in the government; Thoreau uses a metaphor while King uses an illustration in order to establish emotional appeals.
Letter From Birmingham Jail In King's essay, "Letter From Birmingham Jail", King brilliantly employs the use of several rhetorical strategies that are pivotal in successfully influencing critics of his philosophical views on civil disobedience.
Unformatted text preview: “Civil Disobedience” and “Letter to Birmingham Jail” Comparison/Contrast Assignment Directions: Compare and contrast the two texts by documenting examples of the similarities and differences in the chart killarney10mile.com also need to provide specific evidence from the text.
Similarities Differences Evidence from Text %(7). Jul 14, · Comparison of Henry David Thoreau in [Civil Disobedience] and Martin Luther King Jr. in [Letters from Birmingham City Jail] 14 Monday Jul Posted by crystallee97 in English (Writing), School Life (Assignments).Download